What do you want??

scrapser · Joined: 30 Apr 2002 Posts: 211

I understand what you're saying. Not that I really believe this poll will determine what we see in SH4 but even so, I'm sure some of the developers will happen upon it at some point. For that reason, I think the message we should be sending is one that supports developing SH4 (since that's their intention) while asking if it can be done, to include fixes to SH3. Many of the problem areas are not German U-boat specific and it would be nice to have both theaters available in one sim for a change. Nobody's done that before either.

scrapser

1mPHUNit0 · Joined: 11 Jun 2005 Posts: 1

DC2 ofcourse !!!!
A MUST with no stupid smerg.
Razz

Dargo · Joined: 07 Jul 2002 Posts: 158

Destroyer Command II! what else?

raymond6751 · Joined: 17 Mar 2004 Posts: 156 Location: Canada

I want to write in my own log book.
I want possible equipment/engine troubles a la SH1 and 2
I want the varied missions i.e. photo, transport, lifeguard, and
resupply.
I want more realistic responses when I radio my report!
I want to visit the crew / officer quarters and engine room even
if they aren't interactive.
I want the return to port time calculated if we choose not to sail to port.
I want AI subs doing missions too with an updated scorelist when I get into port.
I want a girl when I get to port!!!

Nightowl · Joined: 10 Jan 2002 Posts: 309 Location: Bushnell, FL

todd293 · Joined: 24 Feb 2004 Posts: 85 Location: ohio

I think if sh3 isnt realistic enough for everybody on sh4 they should send along with your game some molded bread along with meat that needs a shave and a m80 to put in your computer monitor so when a depth charge gets to close it will blow up Joking

Kalach · Joined: 08 Apr 2005 Posts: 461 Location: Australia

DC2 sounds fun.
Though I don't want only subs, or only surface ships, I want to be able to play as either. Kind of like DW done SH3 style Very Happy

I guess being able to fly the planes is too much to ask for though...

Most importantly I need it to be a complete (and very moddable) game. With plenty of realism options to choose from.

Also being able to run aroud your entire boat FPS style would be great Thumbs Up

Shigawire · Posted: Sun Dec 25, 2005 5:35 am Post subject:

For me, moddability is numero uno. There is a law of nature which dictates that the ability to add user-content is what helps sustain the life of a product. SH is not exempt from this natural law. Stare

An SDK would be fine. :hmm:

Safe-Keeper · Posted: Sun Dec 25, 2005 5:32 pm Post subject:

All of the above.
I'm not trying to be a smart-ass, that's really what I thought when I saw that.

Sea Demon · Joined: 28 Mar 2004 Posts: 970 Location: USA

1. Silent Hunter IV with a whole new Pacific theatre and playable American and Japanese units.

2. Destroyer Command 2 Rock

JSF · Joined: 07 Jul 2002 Posts: 8

If SH4 is on the same lines as 3 (except being in the Pacific mind you) then the sim will be even more enjoyable. After all the allies did win and I feel playing a sim from the winner's perspective would be refreshing. Thumbs Up

The last 2 sub sims have been about the nazis. :down: The more a read about how the Germans had the best planes and the best subs and so on and so on.....the more it reminds me of those folks in the South who are always engaged in reenacting the Civil War. Damn

BTW...I live in the South....Been there done that.......

Safe-Keeper · Posted: Mon Dec 26, 2005 5:07 pm Post subject:

When I first heard of SH3, my first thought was, "if this has everything SH3 has and more..."

Well, that's still my opinion. If they take all the features from SH3 (minus the glitches, bugs, and exploits Razz

) and add even more features, I'm in Heaven.

finchOU · Joined: 27 Jan 2004 Posts: 486

Weird Guy · Joined: 23 Mar 2005 Posts: 161

My vote is for a Battleship simulator, not a submarine. World War 1 sounds good to me. I've been reading up on that war and the battleships did their job.

But if it is to be a sub sim, then the Pacific theater is alright by me. The only thing to take notice of is a partial map board. Sort of like automatic plotting notes in pencil based on YOUR inputs using the sensor (range and bearing). Not AI autoupdate like a God's Eye View in real time. Just a couple of points noted on a clear map. Measure range using the Stadimeter, and bearing. MARK. The point is put on the map table.

And then tools built in the game to let you measure the plotting table marks to get speed.

finchOU · Joined: 27 Jan 2004 Posts: 486

well I'm glad to see people coming out to vote....

polls been out for almost two weeks now....I'd say its a good sample of how people feel.

I was hoping someone else would come up with a second poll with different options to see if there are any different results....

I didnt feel like the questions I posed were biased in anyway...and I tried to throw everything i could think of out there and put it on the table. Actually the one option I forgot to add until it was too late was "this poll is stupid/is biased/or is pointless" just to see that side of it. Anyone feel they have more/better options ....feel free to make a new poll or expand on mine.... Thumbs Up