[TDK1044]

My mistake. I hated SH11 and only played it a couple of times. I had an old PC that I ran AOD on and I kinda wrote off sub sims until hearing good things about SH111.

[TDK1044]

It's ironic that my old PC that had been updated from windows 95 to windows 98 and which had AOD loaded on it , died on me about a month after I purchased SH11. I think if we got a revamped version of AOD for the Atlantic and SH1V for the PTO, we'd be in heaven.

[CWorth]

Just my opinion but if SHIV were to be in the Atlantic yet again I would not spend a penny on it.I would not care how good it was.

I am getting a bit tired of playing with German U-boats it is not funny.Its high time for another Pacific based game to come out.Only I would like to see it from the Japanese standpoint and not American.But American will be good to though.

I do love SHIII but do need a change of theater.

[Tonnage_Ace]

[Heibges]

I would hope that SH4 has both PTO and ETO.

I must say that they lack of emphasis on ASW by the IJN, combined with the surface and airsearch radars of the USN make the PTO a little boring compared to the ETO.

It's almost impossible to go on patrol in Silent Service or Silent Hunter I and not score 75,000 tons. Both of them really demonstrate the huge advantage radar gave us submarines.

Radar probably makes 1 USN submarine equal to 10 KM uboats.

And because I use hydrophone S.O.P. from the Uboat Commanders Handbook thereby finding most of my targets visually, the advantage of the radar on American submarines is even more pronounced.

On average, I find no targets on 1 out of 3 patrols in the uboats.

[Beery]